Slant Magazine 第一方评分报告:任天堂 vs 索尼

40 款旗舰第一方作品(各 20 款,2014–2026),同时呈现 Slant 评分与 Metacritic / OpenCritic 共识均分。三方统一折算为百分制;Δ = Slant − 共识均分,负值表示 Slant 比同行更苛刻。

总览对比

任天堂73.5
VS
索尼80.5
Slant 评分均分 · 各 20 款
Slant 评分
任天堂73.5
索尼80.5
Metacritic 共识
任天堂88.4
索尼86.5
OpenCritic 共识
任天堂88.2
索尼86.5

注意两条共识条的方向:按 MC / OC,任天堂(88.4 / 88.2)其实略高于索尼(86.5 / 86.5);但在 Slant 这里,索尼反超 7.0 分。

指标任天堂索尼差值(索−任)
收录游戏数2020—
Slant 均分73.580.5+7.0
Slant 中位数7090+20
Slant 最高 / 最低90 / 50100 / 30—
Metacritic 均分88.486.5-1.9
OpenCritic 均分88.286.5-1.8
Slant − MC-14.9-6.0+8.9
Slant − OC-14.8-6.0+8.8
4.5 星及以上5 款12 款+7
低于共识的作品18 / 2012 / 20—
低于共识 ≥20 分6 款3 款-3
高于共识的作品2 款8 款+6

「差值」= 索尼 − 任天堂:绿色表示索尼数值更高,红色表示任天堂数值更高(只标方向,不含优劣判断)。Slant 对任天堂平均扣 14.9 分、对索尼扣 6.0 分,两者相差 8.9 分。

逐款数据按发售年排序 · 点击标题可读 Slant 原文

任天堂第一方年份 · 平台SlantMCOCΔMC评测人
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild 2017 · Switch / Wii U ★★★☆☆60 9796 -37 Jed Pressgrove
Super Mario Odyssey 2017 · Switch ★★★★½90 9797 -7 Jed Pressgrove
Super Smash Bros. Ultimate 2018 · Switch ★★★★½90 9392 -3 Justin Clark
Fire Emblem: Three Houses 2019 · Switch ★★★★½90 8989 +1 Jed Pressgrove
Luigi's Mansion 3 2019 · Switch ★★★★☆80 8685 -6 Ryan Aston
Animal Crossing: New Horizons 2020 · Switch ★★★½☆70 9090 -20 Steven Scaife
Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury 2021 · Switch ★★★★½90 8989 +1 Justin Clark
Metroid Dread 2021 · Switch ★★★★☆80 8887 -8 Justin Clark
Kirby and the Forgotten Land 2022 · Switch ★★★½☆70 8585 -15 Aaron Riccio
Xenoblade Chronicles 3 2022 · Switch ★★½☆☆50 8988 -39 Aaron Riccio
Splatoon 3 2022 · Switch ★★★½☆70 8383 -13 Justin Clark
Pokémon Scarlet & Violet 2022 · Switch ★★½☆☆50 7171 -21 Paul Attard
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom 2023 · Switch ★★★☆☆60 9695 -36 Paul Attard
Pikmin 4 2023 · Switch ★★★½☆70 8788 -17 Mitchell Demorest
Super Mario Bros. Wonder 2023 · Switch ★★★★☆80 9291 -12 Aaron Riccio
The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom 2024 · Switch ★★★½☆70 8585 -15 Justin Clark
Mario Kart World 2025 · Switch 2 ★★★★☆80 8687 -6 Mitchell Demorest
Donkey Kong Bananza 2025 · Switch 2 ★★★★½90 9191 -1 Justin Clark
Metroid Prime 4: Beyond 2025 · Switch 2 ★★★☆☆60 7880 -18 Justin Clark
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026) 2026 · Switch 2 ★★★½☆70 9696 -26 Cole Kronman
索尼第一方年份 · 平台SlantMCOCΔMC评测人
The Last of Us Remastered 2014 · PS4 ★★★★☆80 9594 -15 Justin Clark
The Order: 1886 2015 · PS4 ★½☆☆☆30 6362 -33 Justin Clark
Bloodborne 2015 · PS4 ★★★★½90 9291 -2 Aaron Riccio
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End 2016 · PS4 ★★★★½90 9393 -3 Aaron Riccio
Horizon Zero Dawn 2017 · PS4 ★★★★★100 8989 +11 Justin Clark
God of War 2018 · PS4 ★★★★½90 9494 -4 Justin Clark
Marvel's Spider-Man 2018 · PS4 ★★★½☆70 8788 -17 Steven Scaife
Days Gone 2019 · PS4 ★½☆☆☆30 7172 -41 Steven Scaife
Death Stranding 2019 · PS4 ★★★★½90 8283 +8 Justin Clark
The Last of Us Part II 2020 · PS4 ★★★★½90 9393 -3 Justin Clark
Ghost of Tsushima 2020 · PS4 ★★★½☆70 8384 -13 Justin Clark
Returnal 2021 · PS5 ★★★★½90 8686 +4 Aaron Riccio
Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart 2021 · PS5 ★★★☆☆60 8888 -28 Aaron Riccio
Horizon Forbidden West 2022 · PS4 / PS5 ★★★★½90 8888 +2 Justin Clark
God of War Ragnarök 2022 · PS4 / PS5 ★★★★★100 9492 +6 Justin Clark
Marvel's Spider-Man 2 2023 · PS5 ★★★★★100 9088 +10 Justin Clark
Astro Bot 2024 · PS5 ★★★★★100 9494 +6 Justin Clark
Ghost of Yōtei 2025 · PS5 ★★★★½90 8687 +4 Justin Clark
Saros 2026 · PS5 ★★★★☆80 8787 -7 Niv M. Sultan
Marvel's Wolverine 2026 · PS5 ★★★½☆70 7576 -5 Justin Clark

偏差分布按 Δ 从低到高

任天堂索尼向左 = 低于共识,向右 = 高于共识
Days Gone
-41
Xenoblade Chronicles 3
-39
Zelda: Breath of the Wild
-37
Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
-36
The Order: 1886
-33
Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart
-28
Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026)
-26
Pokémon Scarlet/Violet
-21
Animal Crossing: New Horizons
-20
Metroid Prime 4: Beyond
-18
Pikmin 4
-17
Marvel's Spider-Man
-17
Kirby: Forgotten Land
-15
Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom
-15
The Last of Us (Remastered)
-15
Splatoon 3
-13
Ghost of Tsushima
-13
Super Mario Bros. Wonder
-12
Metroid Dread
-8
Super Mario Odyssey
-7
Saros
-7
Luigi's Mansion 3
-6
Mario Kart World
-6
Marvel's Wolverine
-5
God of War
-4
Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
-3
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End
-3
The Last of Us Part II
-3
Bloodborne
-2
Donkey Kong Bananza
-1
Fire Emblem: Three Houses
+1
Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury
+1
Horizon Forbidden West
+2
Returnal
+4
Ghost of Yōtei
+4
God of War Ragnarök
+6
Astro Bot
+6
Death Stranding
+8
Marvel's Spider-Man 2
+10
Horizon Zero Dawn
+11
−45−220+22+45

40 款中 30 款低于共识、10 款高于共识;高于共识的 10 款里有 8 款来自索尼。

怎么读